Top 3 QBs of All time
Bighersh Alter-Ego
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 178
Likes: 0
From: 33.02N / 96.66W
Originally Posted by dirt bike dave
I agree, there are intangibles outside the stats, and Troy fares pretty well at the 'intangibles'.
Here are a few guys that had the skills + intangibles to take their team to the Super Bowl:
Joe Kapp, Bill Kilmer, Vince Ferragamo, Jim Plunkett, Ron Jaworski, David Woodley, Tony Eason, Jim McMahon, Phil Simms, Doug Williams, Jeff Hosteteler, Mark Rypien, Stan Humphries, Neil O'Donnel, Trent Dilfer, Kerry Collins.
There are some great leaders and fine, top 50 QBs in that list, but no-one that can even sniff the top 3. IMO, Troy has more in common with Plunkett than he does with Elway, Montana, Farve, etc...
Not trying to insult Troy or his fans. Just calling it as I see it - Great player but not top 3.
Here are a few guys that had the skills + intangibles to take their team to the Super Bowl:
Joe Kapp, Bill Kilmer, Vince Ferragamo, Jim Plunkett, Ron Jaworski, David Woodley, Tony Eason, Jim McMahon, Phil Simms, Doug Williams, Jeff Hosteteler, Mark Rypien, Stan Humphries, Neil O'Donnel, Trent Dilfer, Kerry Collins.
There are some great leaders and fine, top 50 QBs in that list, but no-one that can even sniff the top 3. IMO, Troy has more in common with Plunkett than he does with Elway, Montana, Farve, etc...
Not trying to insult Troy or his fans. Just calling it as I see it - Great player but not top 3.
That said, on that string of Super Bowl QB's, none of those QB's would be in my top 10; Doug would be in my top 20 though.