PlastiDip, what do you think?
Both Lowe's and Home Depot should carry it, I've seen it at both. They almost always have black, but should have white, red, some other colors as well. $6 a can, can't beat that.
To anyone still interested in this thread I have a few updates. First of all, the "dip" has been holding up well on my front valance. It hasn't chipped, peeled, flaked, nothing. I recently had the motor out of my truck and during that project we rubbed up against the finish quite a bit. If you happen to get it dirty, Windex will clean it right off and shine it up. Finally, a buddy of mine at Advance Auto Parts told me just the other day that they're now stocking their shelves with PlastiDip
I've used it on a couple of things. One was my Red Honda CRF50 and my chrome Ranger grill. I'll post pics tonight when I get to work. I'm a flat black guy so of course this works for me. Nice "rubbery" feeling too and easy to touch up







