I've had all three in previous trucks. Had Line-x of Memphis spray my 8 ft F250 bed in 2001, I think I paid $499. They did a great job and it held up great for the years I had it. I liked the anti-skid properties, although it can work against you from time to time if you are trying to slide something in or out. Never had any fading or chipping issues. My 2002 F150 came with a Ford drop-in plastic bedliner. Worked ok I guess, except stuff slid all over the place and the grooves trapped anything messy you put in the bed (like mulch, dirt, sand, etc). I got a rubber bed mat for my 2006 F250. I liked it because it was cheap and kept stuff from sliding around. Only downside was the sides of the bed did get scratched occasionally. I'll probably go with another bed mat for my Platinum because for me, it's a good compromise between the spray-in and drop-in liners.