Stock Pump vs. Cobra Pump (good/bad)
#16
Technicaly, there are 2 "cobra pumps". Or I should describe them as being percieved by some aftermarket companies as cobra pumps.
The 96-98 version is actually the same as all the other e-fan 4.6L pumps. T-bird, crown vic, Town car, stang gt, ect....
The real "cobra pump" that uses significantly less power is the small 7 bladed one with a shroud welded to the top of the impeller blades.
Rich
The 96-98 version is actually the same as all the other e-fan 4.6L pumps. T-bird, crown vic, Town car, stang gt, ect....
The real "cobra pump" that uses significantly less power is the small 7 bladed one with a shroud welded to the top of the impeller blades.
Rich
#17
#19
Based on what I have seen on my 96 cobra the water pump referred to as the "cobra" water pump is actually a "cobra R" water pump. The water pump on my 96 cobra looks allot like the 99-02 lightning pump (minus the fan connection shaft) that Speedin Bob has in his post, I cant get a good judgment of the size but it is definitely the same design. The pump that Bob refers to as the 4.6L (aka "Cobra”) is a "Cobra R" pump and is more efficient at pumping water than a regular Cobra water pump. I cannot comment on the power consumption differences of the two because the impellers are of different sizes. One has smaller enclosed impellers and the other has larger open impellers. I will say this, the 03 Lightning water pump looks like it would be the most efficient at pumping water (volume/revolution) but would cost the most power consumption.
Last edited by 03Lightning; 12-11-2003 at 11:27 AM.
#20
Tampa,
Interesting pic. The pump with the open impeller has an additional blade and different blade design than the image I borrowed and posted previously. Thank you for sharing, really.
However, the claim on JDM's website of
creates additional questions. What is/are Ford's factory cooling specs? I'd sure like to know. Hopefully it will be answered by those in the know.
03Lightning,
The part number I posted above is what most, if not all, Lightning/HD vendors are selling. I don't have the time or desire to check them all. They know who they are.
The same part might or might not have been used on the Cobra R. If it was the same part, marketing it as a Cobra R model is fine and dandy but does that make it a better piece? The answer based on my personal experience with the product is an emphatic NO.
If it wasn't used, then marketing it as a Cobra R unit is misleading potential customers and propogates MISinformation on the various forums in plague-like fashion. Clarification on the proper part number used on the Cobra R is warranted at this juncture.
Hopefully someone knows and/or is willing to share.
On a side note and with limited resources available, it appears Ford changed the design and/or part number for the 96-98 4.6L Mustang. Research thus far hasn't produced the associated part number for the years in question.
Bob
Interesting pic. The pump with the open impeller has an additional blade and different blade design than the image I borrowed and posted previously. Thank you for sharing, really.
However, the claim on JDM's website of
(JDM has chosen a high performance water pump which maintains Ford factory cooling specs while decreasing parasitic losses, resulting in a 4-5 HP gain.)
03Lightning,
The part number I posted above is what most, if not all, Lightning/HD vendors are selling. I don't have the time or desire to check them all. They know who they are.
The same part might or might not have been used on the Cobra R. If it was the same part, marketing it as a Cobra R model is fine and dandy but does that make it a better piece? The answer based on my personal experience with the product is an emphatic NO.
If it wasn't used, then marketing it as a Cobra R unit is misleading potential customers and propogates MISinformation on the various forums in plague-like fashion. Clarification on the proper part number used on the Cobra R is warranted at this juncture.
Hopefully someone knows and/or is willing to share.
On a side note and with limited resources available, it appears Ford changed the design and/or part number for the 96-98 4.6L Mustang. Research thus far hasn't produced the associated part number for the years in question.
Bob
#22
#24
Originally posted by wydopnthrtl
I'm frustrated with all the speculation about this subject.
Guys.
The "ford spec" = MY WORK
The "cobra pump" = MY WORK
The *percieved* "cobra R pump" = MY WORK
Every 4.6L, 5.4L, 6.8L pump was engineered by ME working with Ford.
I don't keep track of all the part numbers so don't ask.
Feel free to ask a specific question and I'll give a specific answer.
A water pump and it's matching volute/volutes are designed together to known quantitative values. When we stick something other than what has been design for in it's place? We get a compromise of some sort. Fortunately for this subject, I designed, tested, and tweaked ALL the modular pumps. So I know more than your average bear about it.
Ask away,
Rich
I'm frustrated with all the speculation about this subject.
Guys.
The "ford spec" = MY WORK
The "cobra pump" = MY WORK
The *percieved* "cobra R pump" = MY WORK
Every 4.6L, 5.4L, 6.8L pump was engineered by ME working with Ford.
I don't keep track of all the part numbers so don't ask.
Feel free to ask a specific question and I'll give a specific answer.
A water pump and it's matching volute/volutes are designed together to known quantitative values. When we stick something other than what has been design for in it's place? We get a compromise of some sort. Fortunately for this subject, I designed, tested, and tweaked ALL the modular pumps. So I know more than your average bear about it.
Ask away,
Rich
Last edited by JeffsLightning; 12-12-2003 at 08:29 AM.
#25
#26
wydopnthrtl......
Guys.
The "ford spec" = MY WORK
The "cobra pump" = MY WORK
The *percieved* "cobra R pump" = MY WORK
Every 4.6L, 5.4L, 6.8L pump was engineered by ME working with Ford.
So what you are saying is that you helped design these pumps, but you went ahead and replaced yours with an aftermarket pump????
I just want to see if i understand that right....if that is the case, you may have just sold me on one
Guys.
The "ford spec" = MY WORK
The "cobra pump" = MY WORK
The *percieved* "cobra R pump" = MY WORK
Every 4.6L, 5.4L, 6.8L pump was engineered by ME working with Ford.
So what you are saying is that you helped design these pumps, but you went ahead and replaced yours with an aftermarket pump????
I just want to see if i understand that right....if that is the case, you may have just sold me on one
#28
So what you are saying is that you helped design these pumps, but you went ahead and replaced yours with an aftermarket pump????
And NO I have not replaced my pump. Where did that question come from?
All these "aftermarket" pumps.... Well I can't tip my hand there. But I'll say that the quality of them is the same as the OEM :wink wink:
TampaBlack99,
There has never been a flow test done of the two in question. So I cannot answer that one.
I will say however that a cobra pump (either one) that's in a truck block will flow less than it would in a real cobra block. The distance between the "strippers" on the block & the impeller tips will have a much larger gap. Thus lowering the efficiency of the impeller moving the fluid.
There are only 2 real things gained by doing this. Virtually no cavitation will occur at high rpms & the pump will consume less power to turn.
Rich
Last edited by wydopnthrtl; 12-12-2003 at 01:13 PM.