I'm leaning towards the AFE Pro Dry S Air Filter mainly because its a dry filter and not oiled like the K&N....has anyone used the AFE or have a better option for a reusable air filter?

FYI I have a 2010 and from what I read an CAI is just a waste of money so I don't want to go that route.

 

I've got an amsoil oil free filter and it's great

 

I don't think you will get any measurable increase in performance by doing this. The stock air filter is huge on your truck, and probably cleans better than a 'higher flow' model. The bobistheoilguy site did some testing a few years ago, and found almost no performance increase and slightly dirtier air by going this route.