for tips which is more important for loudness?
Both really if you think of it. If you have say a 3" system with a 3.5" tip, the longer the exhaust note has to bounce in a larger area the louder. I don't think it's a huge difference but probably some. Most important is the diameter and then comes length. For kicks try making noise in a few pipes of the same diameter, just different lengths, see what results from it.


