Which to get really depends on how you use your truck bed. For me I like the drop-in. I like being able to slide things around. For when you don't want things to slide, the new cargo management system would be great. I think the spray-in looks best, but this doesn't work best for me. I vote for the drop-in.

 

Iv'e had spay in and just the rubber mat. My vote is just the rubber mat. Anti skid, easy to clean and removable to clean the bed. There is a rubber tail gate protector too. You have to screw it in but just drill the corner and centers and use double sided tape for the rest. Plastic liners hold water and there is no good coming from that. Spray in is expensive and heavy. why carry all that weight around?
Good luck.

 

Since I started this last year just to get some thoughts I went with the

Ford bed mat. My truck has the tailgate step that has a cover on tail gate.

Also have the pickup bed extender which can help secure loads. But over all

with the mat, not big cost does the job, does not beat up bed underneath

and wear the paint off. More than satisfied. Line-X was just too much and

they could not color match the Platinum White Sand.