Changing my spark plug's today!
I really can't believe that there are still people defending Ford and saying that there isn't a problem. If even one person breaks a spark plug trying to remove it, then there is a problem. The fact that Ford has developed a special process and tool to remove the plugs is proof that there is a problem. Sure, there may be some success stories, but how many other vehicle's owners have to talk about success stories when it comes to replacing their plugs? I bet if you go over to the Titan or Silverado or Tundra or Ram forums, they're not talking about their plugs or the success stories when none of them break.
Very risky move on your part sporting that!
It was a stupid design and should never have happened, but I think the failures do get publicized more than the successes. On another site, thy had a poll. The success rate was like 76% for getting them all out.
__________________
Jim
Jim
I disagree completely. Call Bankston Ford in Burleson, TX and ask them how many they have had break. I think that us do it yourselfers have more break than the experts, because we don't have the experience to know when to back off and do it safely.
It was a stupid design and should never have happened, but I think the failures do get publicized more than the successes. On another site, thy had a poll. The success rate was like 76% for getting them all out.
It was a stupid design and should never have happened, but I think the failures do get publicized more than the successes. On another site, thy had a poll. The success rate was like 76% for getting them all out.
I disagree completely. Call Bankston Ford in Burleson, TX and ask them how many they have had break. I think that us do it yourselfers have more break than the experts, because we don't have the experience to know when to back off and do it safely.
It was a stupid design and should never have happened, but I think the failures do get publicized more than the successes. On another site, thy had a poll. The success rate was like 76% for getting them all out.
It was a stupid design and should never have happened, but I think the failures do get publicized more than the successes. On another site, thy had a poll. The success rate was like 76% for getting them all out.
Yep, That has always been my concern. I suspect some of that goes on.
__________________
Jim
Jim
I agree. I went to an independent garage. When they broke 2 of them I raised holy hell because I told them to take all week if they had to. Nope, they insisted on trying to get them out in 4 hours.
That's good to hear, but if you know anything about statistics, you know that the entire polling on a website is flawed. You only get a very small sample of the population, and the people who are polled are much more informed that there is even an issue, so they use the "magical" process in the TSB which does increase the "success rate". How many F150 owners (as a percentage) do you think actually read or post on online message boards and are even aware that there is an issue? I have always changed my own plugs on all my vehicles I have ever owned. I never relied on an online message board to tell me that changing them would be a chore, and fortunately no other vehicle I ever owned had any issue with changing plugs. I equate it to there being an issue when changing the oil in a vehicle. To me, changing the plugs is like changing the oil. It is a basic maintenance item that should be quick and easy.
You are arguing with the wall. We are saying mostly the same thing. It's a ridiculous problem to have. Ford made a blunder. But the original statement that I responded to of "more break than do not", I still think is wrong.
I have always changed my on plugs. This is the first vehicle that I haven't. It galled me to think what I paid for the plug change till I did the math. I used to change them at 12,000 miles in my old Fords. Paid about $15 for plugs, These go near 100,000, it all evens out when I put a labor charge on my DIY changes.
__________________
Jim
Jim
i changed mine at 50k and i got lucky but i followed the tsb anally. Now i replaced the plugs following the tsb to the letter with motorcraft antiseize. when i hit 100k im gonna change em again.
Do i need to follow the tsb again? how is it changing plugs after you apply antiseize to the elcectrode shield thing?
How are any alternative sparkplugs like champion and brisk or whatever
Do i need to follow the tsb again? how is it changing plugs after you apply antiseize to the elcectrode shield thing?
How are any alternative sparkplugs like champion and brisk or whatever
No one said there is not a problem. No one said that there is not a serious problem. No one said it is not a stupid problem to have to deal with. All I said was that I think there is a lot more success getting them out than people realize. I said that in reponse to the post taht said there are more breaking than not breaking. I do not belieive that at all.
I fully beleive that if you use a gas with a good detergent and follow the TSB explicitly, you have a high likelyhood of being successful. Should it be something we have to discuss? No, not saying that at all.
I fully beleive that if you use a gas with a good detergent and follow the TSB explicitly, you have a high likelyhood of being successful. Should it be something we have to discuss? No, not saying that at all.
I know that your not trying to defend the plug's or Ford but all I have ran in my truck since I purchased it at 62,000 mile's is Chevron and Texaco gas. I still don't understand why this plug broke cause the other one's looked so clean. Every Ford dealership i've been to so far has said that the only plug that ever breaks on them is the one that broke with me. The back driver's side plug. I'm still fighting with this thing and not a single shop around is open today. Look's like my whole weekend is gonna be wasted trying to do a sparkplug change.

That sucks, and I'm sorry to hear you still haven't gotten the plug out. Good luck with it. It sounds like you are a lot like me...not willing to give up until it is fixed. I'm sure you will eventually get it out, even if it means pulling the head. I know that if you pull the head, you also have to pull the intake. Doing so, would you have to replace the head gasket on that side and the intake gaskets on both heads as well?
Last edited by 2004Triton5.4; Mar 21, 2009 at 04:14 PM.




