The BEDRUG is the best investment. I will have bedrugs in all my future trucks because of the great service I have now. It looks show quality, but you can still use the bed for everyday items.

 

BEDRUG!!

I have hauled stuff in it and with my hard tonneau cover its like having a huge trunk..
I tell people that my L is like having a Boxster with a huge trunk, only faster... and cheaper, except on gas..
Good luck with whatever you decide..
Dana

 

If you get the bedrug first, if you dont like it, you can prob sell it in a heartbeat and get the liner. Spray in liners are pretty hard to remove if you dont like them though.. or you could do the spray in and put the rug on top.. although that would be pretty expensive..
Dana

 

My BedRug is going on 5yrs now, on its second truck. I have hauled everything from fill dirt to slicks. Its still in great shap, and as was said, try it first. If you don't like it go for the spray in liner.
Good luck with your decision

 

Bedrug does pretty darn good, have had mine for 2+ years, no top of any kind. Some slight fading due to SoCal sun, and one of the velcro strips securing the tailgate broke, but replaced it in 10 seconds.

I did have a problem with a slight depression in the floor of the bedrug where I was hauling my road bike where the rear tire always rested, but I see now that it has flattened out with time, I think solar heating caused it to flatten back out.

I occasionally rinse it out at the carwash.

I am in a marine climate .5 mile from ocean in Santa Barbara and no mildew or rust anywhere.