I am thinking of a another boat and trade mine in.. what do you all think??.
used 1986 20' thompson cuddy= 5500

or
used 4 wynns 17ft

or
also used 23.5 ft (my favorite so far)

or should i just go new. This is lake erie so the seasons short round here, maybe new is no worth it...
thanks

 

My dad bought a four winns similar to that one that you posted and he absolutely loves it. It's definitely all purpose fishing and towing. And it's funny that you posted that Thompson because my grandfather had that exact same boat color and everything but he sold it about 10 years ago, but that was alot of fun too. I'd say go with the used Four Winns.

 

Wow Buck. They're all so cool. As a woman though, I need to see the inside. You know, the seats and all. And the toilet.

 

The toilet.... that's why you just jump in

 

I tried peeing off the side and it just doesn't work. Need a terlet. And terlet paper!!!!

 

I'm inclined to agree with you on the #3 choice. . .I like the color

 

I forgot your from Jersey... you city girls don't like to get dirty too much.

 

Well it depends what you mean by "dirty". If you mean do I need toilet paper, yes I do. If you mean can I pee in the ocean, no I can't.

If you mean something else....?

 

 

Hey Buck is the bow on that 23.5 enclosed or open. I guess that would probably be the deciding factor for me. The Four Winns being open would be good because of the obvious open bow space but if a closed bow works better for you as far as stowing gear and what not I guess that would be the way to go.

 

no its a cuddy, but is pretty nice. i do like the open bow so maybe...

yes LT is has a head.

the motor is very clean

 

If it has a head, get it......don't forget to swing by Jersey and pick me up for the test drive. I'll christian the head for you!!!!

 

Wow those pics change things a little. I really like it. But I think it will definitely come down to open or closed bow. I think if you have alot of people on the boat the open bow is definitely the way to go. Either way your gonna have fun so I guess it's good no matter which one you choose.

 

That is a pretty boat Jim

 

Once again another quote that's gonna get you into trouble. I don't know how you do it but you do.