If it really IS an incosistancy, would you please clue us in?
I thought it tied up everything really well...Not to say that there's no possibility that I didn't miss something (had a pair of 17 month olds with us), but I got everything I was looking for...

 

I had 5:00 tickets, but I had to trade them in for the 7:00 show. I got there at 5:45 and there ws still about 30 people in front of me - I still manged to get the best seats - dead center, with the middle of the screen at eye level (stadium seating is the way to go!)

The movie kicks ***! Waaaayyyyyyyyy better than I and II, and probably better than the orignal trilogy. The part that sucks is that you know already how the movie has to end.

Vader716 - email me with what you think is the inconsistency.

 

Wow - you da man! I wanted to take my 2 year old, but I thought it was going to be to dark for her. Unfortunately, she'll have to wait a few years to see it - which bites because she already loves the other 5 movies. So far they are the only non-aminated shows that keep her attention.

 

I have never seen Titanic, I got sick of the previews and the hype and refused to watch the damn thing!! The boat sank....get over it!

I would like to see Episode III but I will probably wait until it comes out in video, I'm just not much of a theater buff. I like the privacy and comfort of my recliner. I don't have a huge TV (32" Flat screen) but we do have surround sound that can blow the windows out of the neighbors house! And as soon as they come out in a boxed set I plan on picking them up, I already have the first 3 movies!!

 

Here is my possible inconsistency....like I said I'm not sure yet...

Geek warning...




Possible Spoiler alert








Last warning...





Ok.

In Jedi, Luke and Leia are talking on the Moon of Endor before he goes to confront Vader and he asks Leia to tell him about their mother, "I never knew her he said". Leia answers with something similiar to "I don't remember much, feelings MOSTLY, but she was sad, etc".

If Luke and Leia were split up and given away at birth and Amidala dies at birth how does Leia have any more first hand knowledge of their mother than he?

Got to watch that scene to verify the exact wording but I figured Amidala would live with Senator Organa for a few year 2-3 before dying of grief.

Thoughts?

 

Geek warning...




Possible Spoiler alert








Last warning...





Ok.
Just one.....





GEEK!!!!

 

I know I know....I accept it

 

Without reading Vader's post (I haven't seen the movie yet, but I have read the book) there is an inconsistency revealed in Jedi that from what I've read in the novel, and tying back to Episode I, don't align quite right...

But, it's no biggie- it's still a great movie franchise...

Besides, Lucas said in Entertainment magazine that the material he had for prequels was admittedly thin (As I properly specultated it was).

________________

OK, freek-it, I read Vader's post. Yes, that's another inconsistency. Perhaps Lucas should not have Padme punch out like that. There is another stated in Ben's conversation w/Luke in RotJ.

 

I think Leia had "the force" in her blood like her brother Luke. She just didn't utilize it. I mean they are bro and sis, you'd think they'd have the same bloodline? In Clone wars, when Anikin and Obi-Wan got on that starship (can't remember the name), they were trying not to let anyone see them. And Anikin sensed that someone or something was near, but Obi-Wan told him he was imagining things. Next thing you know these robots were shooting lasers at them. Anikan was right. Because he had a stronger sense by utilizing the force. I think he was on top of his game at a young age, btw. They can sense when something wrong is about to happen, and they can sense feelings. Anikan (Vader) is Luke's father. Ok got that much? That makes Luke his Son. Lukes sister is Leia. Now put two and two together and see that Leia "somewhat" had a strong sense of her Mother's feelings because of "the force" in her blood. Even while in the womb. That's my opinion.

 

Right, Amidala died from a broken heart, and just as Yoda could feel the pain of the Jedi being turned on and killed, Leia, even though she was just born, felt Amidala's pain so strongly that it allowed her to remember at least that she was sad...Or something like that...

Luke couldn't remember anything about her because he was
a.) Way too whiney to remember his mother...
b.) He was too focused on Vader...

 

Luke said to Leia, do you remeber your mother, she said something along the lines of, "No not much, I remeber she was very beautiful, she died when I was young."
Bail Organa's wife, Leia's adopted mother must die at a young age. Leia didn't know she was adopted until she found out that she was Luke's sister.

 

My eyes arent yellow.

 

Thats what I was thinking too 36fan

 

Don't think that flies. Like I said I'll double check it in my geek library but her reaction would have been much different if she found out:

A. She was adopted.
B. Luke was her brother.
C. She frenched her brother in ESB.

 

Peacemaker brought up a good idea too.

Me? I am just waiting for Vader to break into the "geek library".