But has anyone had these carpeted catchalls through a snowy northern winter? I highly doubt they'd come out of a snowy northern winter in one piece or not looking like crap.

 

I had these in my 2002 F-150 and immediately ordered them for my 2005 F-150. They hold up really well to everything that I have thrown at them. My Dad has gotten grease on them and it has come off with some scrubbing. I believe that the carpet is made from some synthetic fiber that resists staining. It really looks nice in the Lariat trucks. Too bad that the trucks don't come with these from the factory. Also, I have had the Husky's in another truck and felt that they slide around more than these do.

Here is a pic.

 

We have the same color truck and mats irhogfan. I agree they look awesome and hold up very well. Mine are 6 mos old and 16k miles and they look new. I just use a cheap upholstery cleaner from Auto Zone on mine and they clean right up. Yellow bottle, called TUFF I believe...good stuff.

 

I have the carpeted Catch-All's and love them. I had them in my Ranger for 4 years and they held up very well.

There are pics of them in MY GALLERY

 

I have the F150 inscribed rubber catchalls in mine, awesome! I just hose em off when dirty, and doesn't get dirty and dingy like carpet mats, although in the Lariat or King Ranch, carpets are nice.

 

Both types of mats are great, we all use our trucks for different types of applications and in different environments.

On my wifes new EXPY I got the Catch-All carpeted mats in the front and Husky one piece second row and cargo mat. My Brother in law already spilled half a can of coke on the Huskys in the second row seats, all I had to do was wipe them off with a sponge, excellent.

For my work truck though I'm getting the Weathertech Extremes. I don't want a carpeted mat that will pick up fish gurry off my boots and stink forever.

If I lived in the South and didn't work in mud or around fish, I would own the Catch-Alls. They fit really nice and are the plushest floormats I've used.

 

I just got 2 sets of black Weathertechs by mistake for the front.(one set going back this week) They fit really nice and give good grip. I just think they are way over priced and kinda cheap feeling for the price. $93 is pretty expensive for front mats but we will see how they hold up this winter. We destroyed my wifes 05 Tahoes mats this past winter.