I have on 01 single cab with 33in trail grapplers on 17 American racing justice wheels with daystar keys installed. I have a chance to get a 4.5" Ezride lift for 200+ my factory susp. So question is would it look dumb with only 33s an that much lift? Don't have the 1300$ for bigger tires an mine are still 3/4 tread any pics?

 

It will look fin if you use a 10 inch wide wheel and a wide (at least 12.50 inch/305 mm) tire. I'd also ditch the aftermarket keys and use your stock ones.

 

id do it i ran my 5" rough country with 33"s for a couple months before i had the funds for 35s it doesnt look bad. Also its truck all that matters is if you like it or not no one elses opinion matters.