Thanks guys! I did not notice that there was a second button because it was dark out when I tried to remove the headrest. I did not come across instructions in the owners manual so I figured I would ask to see if anyone had the same issue. I will try it in the morning. =)
2009 Regular Cab XL, Long Bed, 5.4L.
Mods: PTM mirror caps, tailgate handle and front grill. Power locks. Alarm system. Tinted windows. 265 Bridgestone Revo 2's.