Rhino vs. Line X
There has probably been a discussion about this in the past...but I've been doing a little research on both companies and had some specific questions/comments.
I'm looking to do a spray in application so that I can have a durable, good looking bed liner....that will last forever.
Pricing really isn't a concern for me, since I doubt there will be a significant difference in either application and when it comes down to it, I'm going to pick whichever I have the most confidence regardless of the price...it's a permanent addition after all.
I have heard Line X say that they are superior to Rhino due to the Rhino application being a "cold application", something that would negatively impact the settling of the product in the bed (unevenness, etc) ...however I called a Rhino dealer and specifically asked about this and they told me that their product is applied at 200 some degrees and dries within 8 seconds…assuring an even application throughout the bed.
I have also noticed that Line X seems to pride itself on making sure any bolts, drain holes or what not are not simply sprayed over, making them impossible to access after being sprayed...saying Rhino will just spray over such items....not sure why they would do such a thing....or even if so, if you could simply tell them not to.
I have read on the net Rhino applications fading fairly quickly...I asked a Rhino dealer about this as well...and he had told me after a few years it may fade, but there is a product which can be applied if and when that happens, making the surface shine like new again. Not sure if in some way the Line X product is more resistant to fading, due to UV rays.
Lastly, Line X claims Rhino applications to be chalky and having a "cottage cheese" like appearance, while their applications look as if they came from the factory.
Right now I'm leaning towards Line X...but would like others opinions as well as additional information...or any corrections to information which I have gathered so far. I know there are numerous Line X dealers posting on the forums, try to be as unbiased as possible.
[quote]Originally posted by sportf150 Rhino vs. Line X
There has probably been a discussion about this in the past...
Boy is that an understatement.....You're going to find guys and gals who like both and recommend both. I have Line-X and am completely satisified with it. I have had no experience with Rhino other than what research I did. IMO I think Line-X looks better and it is tougher. You've probably already have been shown, but if you rub Line-X and Rhino together the Rhino will start flaking off like an eraser.
Like so many mods we do on our trucks it all comes down to personal preference. As long as you like it who cares what anyone else thinks. And, welcome to the site lots of great info here.
__________________
2004 FX4 SCAB
Gray Leather Power Captian's Seats
Access Tonneau Cover
MAAP Challenger Steps
Putco Side Locker Rails
I'm just trying to weigh the pros and possibly cons to each only in regards to quality...to me, they both look the same anyway...but then again I haven't seen them both up close to compare the two side by side.
How long have you had your Line X and have you had any problems with it fading as of yet?
I've only had mine since the beginning of January and have only hauled a couple loads of hay, so it still looks new. Plus I have a tonneau cover over the bed so there won't be any sun fading.
A buddy of mine has had his Line-X since Nov. 2003 in his F-150. He does not have a tonneau cover and uses his bed pretty hard on occasion, loading 8 foot pine logs, moving gravel, loading and unloading ATV and his has held up very well. He did have to have the tail gate re-sprayed, loading ATV with chains on, tore liner a bit. Repair was done free of charge and without question, looked as good as new.
__________________
2004 FX4 SCAB
Gray Leather Power Captian's Seats
Access Tonneau Cover
MAAP Challenger Steps
Putco Side Locker Rails
LINE-X: Made of a polyurethane/polyurea blend. Harder than Rhino. Tear strength=304 pli, temp tolerance=250 degrees, dries in 4 seconds, more dense of a product because the polyurea keeps moisture out of the resin prior to spraying, written nationwide lifetime warranty.
Rhino: Made of 100% polyurethane. Softer than LINE-X-you can dig your nail into it. Tear strength=145 pli, temp tolerance=175 degrees, takes 20 to 30 seconds to gel-takes 45 minutes to dry, warranty is only with the dealer that sprayed it.
Originally posted by TruckGasm Yep, it's been discussed a BUNCH.
LINE-X: Made of a polyurethane/polyurea blend. Harder than Rhino. Tear strength=304 pli, temp tolerance=250 degrees, dries in 4 seconds, more dense of a product because the polyurea keeps moisture out of the resin prior to spraying, written nationwide lifetime warranty.
Rhino: Made of 100% polyurethane. Softer than LINE-X-you can dig your nail into it. Tear strength=145 pli, temp tolerance=175 degrees, takes 20 to 30 seconds to gel-takes 45 minutes to dry, warranty is only with the dealer that sprayed it.
well according to the rhino websites i've looked at..they will honor the warranty at any rhino location... nonetheless... line x still seems like a better product.
Go with the line-x. I've had four of them over the years and they look awesome and dont fade in the Texas sun. Here at work we quit using rhino because they would fade to chalky looking in a month or so on new unsold trucks!
Originally posted by SAJEFFC Go with the line-x. I've had four of them over the years and they look awesome and dont fade in the Texas sun. Here at work we quit using rhino because they would fade to chalky looking in a month or so on new unsold trucks!
Thanks for the input!
I am glad I stumbled upon the Line X product on the web before just going with Rhino, the name I had most commonly heard.
Another question about Line X...
Any problems with the product rubbing off onto items in the bed? Have heard of some spray in liners leaving residue behind ..i.e. leaving black residue on your butt if you should happen to sit on the bed.
You will absolutely not have that problem with LINE-X.
About Rhino's warranty: I just looked at their site, which by the way, has recently changed. I did not find any mention of a warranty. About 6 months ago, I called Rhino and asked them directly to make sure that the info I bring to the forums is correct. At that time, they told me that the warranty is only with the dealer that sprayed it.
If you saw warranty info on their site, please give us the link. Thanks!
Originally posted by TruckGasm You will absolutely not have that problem with LINE-X.
About Rhino's warranty: I just looked at their site, which by the way, has recently changed. I did not find any mention of a warranty. About 6 months ago, I called Rhino and asked them directly to make sure that the info I bring to the forums is correct. At that time, they told me that the warranty is only with the dealer that sprayed it.
If you saw warranty info on their site, please give us the link. Thanks!
"Q. What type of warrantee do you provide?
A. As an Authorized Rhino Linings Dealer we provide you with an unlimited lifetime warrantee which includes material and labor costs against peeling, chipping or cracking for as long as you own the truck. Damage caused by abuse or by an accident are not covered
Q. Is my Rhino Linings Warrantee Good anywhere in the US?
A. Yes, Rhino Linings USA, Inc. has over 500 authorized dealers throughout the USA. You can take your truck to any of them provided you show them your receipt of purchase. "
....I think I've heard Line X will repair regardless...what really qualifies as "abuse" anyway...using the liner as it was intended to be used?
..let me know about this one please (Line X conditions of warranty)
"Rhino Linings is the largest and most widely recognized manufacturer of sprayed-on polyurethane linings in the world, and the Rhino Linings brand is the undisputed leader and the brand customers ask for by name. "
I recently spoke to a Rhino dealer in MO, at an outdoor show. Asked the question about national coverage. He told me that there is a form of national warranty for Rhino. The process requires Rhino, Inc. to approve a repair at a new facility.
That site is not their corporate site. But nevertheless, I will call Rhino corporate (again) directly and report back.
I have heard that in 2004, LINE-X overtook Rhino in market share. I'm going to a regional LINE-X meeting next saturday. All the big wigs will be there. I'll let you know what I find out.
Check out the Dualcomp Bedliners, it solves all the issues of both the drop ins and the spray ins - and looks good for an extended period of time, no "annual tune-up" required!
Looks a little cheesy, at least from the pictures on the website I'm looking at. It seems like the wheel well covers are something...not sure how to describe it.
Maybe it is the website or just me. I'm sure it is a fine alternative but I can't see how it touches a linex, other than the non skid bit. Could you shovel out of if or would that tear the rubber.
Depending upon the cost it would definitely be a better choice than a drop in.
This forum is owned and operated by Internet Brands, Inc., a Delaware corporation. It is not authorized or endorsed by the Ford Motor Company and is not affiliated with the Ford Motor Company or its related companies in any way. Ford® is a registered trademark of the Ford Motor Company
Linear Mode
